Iraqi Miracle
Preoccupied as it was poring over Tom Daschle’s tax returns, Washington hardly noticed a near-miracle abroad. Iraq held provincial elections. There was no Election Day violence. Security was handled by Iraqi forces with little U.S. involvement. A fabulous bazaar of 14,400 candidates representing 400 parties participated, yielding results highly favorable to both Iraq and the United States.
Iraq moved away from religious sectarianism toward more secular nationalism. “All the parties that had the words ‘Islamic’ or ‘Arab’ in their names lost,” noted Middle East expert Amir Taheri. “By contrast, all those that had the words ‘Iraq’ or ‘Iraqi’ gained.” Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki went from leader of a small Islamic party to leader of the “State of Law Party,” campaigning on security and secular nationalism. He won a smashing victory. His chief rival, a more sectarian and pro-Iranian Shiite religious party, was devastated.
Another major Islamic party, the pro-Iranian Sadr faction, went from 11 percent of the vote to 3 percent, losing badly in its stronghold of Baghdad. The Islamic Fadhila party that had dominated Basra was almost wiped out.
The once-dominant Sunni party affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood and the erstwhile insurgency was badly set back. New grass-roots tribal (“Awakening”) and secular Sunni leaders emerged.
All this barely pierced the consciousness of official Washington. After all, it fundamentally contradicts the general establishment/media narrative of Iraq as “fiasco.” One leading conservative thinker had concluded as early as 2004 that democracy in Iraq was “a childish fantasy.” Another sneered that the 2005 election that brought Maliki to power was “not an election but a census” — meaning people voted robotically according to their ethnicity and religious identity.
The implication being that these primitives have no conception of democracy, and that trying to build one there is a fool’s errand.
What was lacking in all this condescension is what the critics so pride themselves in having — namely, context. What did they expect in the first elections after 30 years of totalitarian rule that destroyed civil society and systematically annihilated any independent or indigenous leadership? The only communal or social ties remaining after Saddam Hussein were those of ethnicity and sect.
But in the intervening years, while the critics washed their hands of Iraq, it began developing the sinews of civil society: a vibrant free press, a plethora of parties, the habits of negotiation and coalition-building. Reflecting these new realities, Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani this time purposely and publicly backed no party, strongly signaling a return — contra Iran — to the Iraqi tradition of secular governance.
The big strategic winner here is the United States. The big loser is Iran. The parties Tehran backed are in retreat. The prime minister who staked his career on a strategic cooperation agreement with the United States emerged victorious.
Moreover, this realignment from enemy state to emerging democratic ally, unlike Egypt’s flip from Soviet to U.S. ally in the 1970s, is not the work of a single autocrat (like Anwar Sadat), but a reflection of national opinion expressed in a democratic election.
This is not to say that these astonishing gains are irreversible. There loom three possible threats: (a) a coup from a rising and relatively clean military disgusted with the corruption of civilian politicians — the familiar post-colonial pattern of the past half-century; (b) a strongman emerging from a democratic system (Maliki?) and then subverting it, following the Russian and Venezuelan models; or (c) the collapse of the current system because of a premature U.S. withdrawal that leads to a collapse of security.
Averting the first two is the job of Iraqis. Averting the third is the job of the United States. Which is why President Obama’s reaction to these remarkable elections, a perfunctory statement noting that they “should continue the process of Iraqis taking responsibility for their future,” was shockingly detached and ungenerous.
When you become president of the United States you inherit its history, even the parts you would have done differently. Obama might argue that American sacrifices in Iraq were not worth what we achieved. But for the purposes of current and future policy, that is entirely moot. Despite Obama’s opposition, America went on to create a small miracle in the heart of the Arab Middle East. President Obama is now the custodian of that miracle. It is his duty as leader of the nation that gave birth to this fledgling democracy to ensure that he does nothing to undermine it.
Iraq: Good News Is No News
By Charles Krauthammer, Washington Post
Friday, February 13, 2009; Page A17
Looking around…
I love to browse in various places on the online world, regularly I will just go to Digg and read and check stuff out…
Weebly article…
I saw a guy talking a lot about this on Tumblr and it linked right to…
Weebly article…
I saw a girl writing a lot about this on Tumblr and it linked right to…
Iron Man 3…
I have to get across my appreciation for your generosity supporting visitors who require help on that matter. Your special dedication to getting the solution all around ended up being wonderfully functional and has always encouraged girls just like me …
Thanks a lot|Thanks a ton|Warm regards|With thanks}; from {all of us|each one of us|everyone of us}….
Iron Man 3…
Looking around…
I love to look a bit around the vast web, quite regularly I will just go to Stumble Upon and follow thru…
Bing results…
While browsing a bit Bing and Yahoo I happily found this page in the search results and I do not think it match…
Weebly article…
I saw a guy writing a lot about this on Tumblr and it linked right to…
Useful and precise…
Its difficult to find really informative and precise information but here I found…
Looking around…
I love to look a bit in various places on the vast online world, quite regularly I will go to Stumble Upon and read and check stuff out…
Just Looking…
When I was browsing a bit this week end I noticed a good article concerning…
Looking around…
I love to look a bit in various places on the vast online world, quite often I will go to Digg and follow thru…
News info…
I was reading the news and I saw this really interesting topic…
Iron Man 3…
Thank you so much for giving everyone remarkably brilliant possiblity to discover important secrets from this website. It is always very kind plus full of fun for me personally and my office peers to search your site really 3 times in one week to read …
Just Browsing…
While I was browsing today I noticed a excellent article about…
Informative and precise…
Its difficult to find informative and precise information but here I noted…
Looking around…
I love to browse in various places on the internet, often I will just go to Stumble Upon and read and check stuff out…
Much Thanks!…
Thanks for taking the time to provide us all with the info!…
Just Browsing…
While I was browsing yesterday I noticed a great post concerning…